This is an important legal question, "who can decide wheither a patent is "obvious" a jury or judge? The moving parties in this case believe that only a "judge" is qualified to decide this important question. When retained an expert intellectual property witness like Leo Stoller can help the judge or jury decide whether a patent is obvious and should die or whether the patent is not obvious and shall live. In intellectual property cases which involve millions of dollars in potential damages a good expert can help decide the case in favor of the party that retains him. Stoller can be reached at 312-545-4554, Ldms4@hotmail.com 7115 W. North Ave Chicago, Illinois 60302. One fact for sure is for a party to go into intellectual property litigation without a expert witness will certainly lead to a huge damage award against that party.