THE APPELLATE COURTS DO NOT ALWAYS GET IT RIGHT EITHER

3/8/2010

WASHINGTON-D.C.-(AEAE)- APPELLATE COURT DO NOT ALWAYS GET IT RIGHT. The United States Supreme Court issued a decision inREED ELSEVIER, INC., ET AL. v. MUCHNICK ET AL. On March 3, 2010 reversing the THE SECOND CIRCUIT in a copyright case. The Copyright Act (Act) generally requires copyright holders to register their works before suing for copyright infringement. 17 U. S. C. A. §411(a). The complaint in this consolidated, class-action copyright in fringement suit alleged that the named plaintiffs each own at least one copyright, typically in a freelance article written for a newspaper or magazine, that they had registered in accordance with §411(a).. The parties moved the District Court to certify a settlement class and approve a settlement agree ment. The District Court did so over the objections of some freelance authors. On appeal, the Second Circuit sua sponte raised the question whether §411(a) deprives federal courts of subject-matter jurisdiction over infringement claims involving unregistered copyrights, concluding that the District Court lacked jurisdiction to certify the class or approve the settlement. The U.S Supreme Court reversed. The Second Circuit sua sponte committed reversble error. Click on the attached link to read the whole opinion http://www.supremecourtus.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-103.pdf Leo Stoller is the nations leading Intellectual Property and Appellate court Expert [email protected]

11 Comments

EQUAL JUSTICE PARTY
Internships not available now

Help the Equal Justice Party www. equaljusticeparty.org a registered political party in Illinois, support conservative candidates and endorses AEAE. Contribute today!
FREE SPEECH ON THE NET IS NOT 'FREE'. PEOPLE GO TO JAIL FOR BLOGGING ALL OF THE TIME. THE EQUAL JUSTICE PARTY IS FIGHTING TO MAINTAIN THE FIRST AMENDMENT WHICH IS SUPPOSE TO GUARANTEE FREEDOM OF SPEECH. , the First Amendment means that government has no power to restrict expression because of its message, its ideas, its subject matter, or its content." Police Dep't of Chicago v. Mosley, 408 U.S. 92, 95, 33 L. Ed. 2d 212, 92 S. Ct. 2286 (1972); see also Consolidated Edison Co. v. Public Serv. Comm'n, 447 U.S. 530, 537, 65 L. Ed. 2d 319, 100 S. Ct. 2326 (1980)

YOU CAN SUPPORT FREEDOM OF SPEECH BY SUPPORTING THE EQUAL JUSTICE PARTY. DONATE ON-LINE
Supporting Equal Justice Party helps to maintain the Internet a free voice and EJ supports the First Amendment of the U.S Constitution.
The Equal Justice Party (EJ) is a registered Political Action Committee in Chicago, Illinois S 10127 L 15656. The EJ supports conservative causes, conservative candidates, small government.
Americans for the Enforcement of Attorney Ethics (AEAE) www.rentamark.net is a not for profit group that supports Equal Justice www.equaljustice.org and advocates the strict enforcement of attorney ethics since 1974.
The purpose of the AEAE Blog is to exalt the law, by holding to the fundamental right of “Equal Justice” for all. It keeps “watch” on attorney and judicial misconduct issues, evolving trademark and constitutional law. It assures all people with the “good news” that in American “right” will prevail especially for those who “never” give-up “fighting” to obtain “justice”. This site adheres to the Law and the Constitution as its authority. The AEAE, is a attorney rating Service. The comments made by AEAE are not actionable because they are statements of opinion Moriarty v. Greene 732 N.E.2d 730, 740 Ill.App), citing Owen v. Can 497 N.E.2d 1145, 1148 (Ill.1986) see Law offices of David Freydin,PC v Vitoria Chamara et al No 18-3216 Seventh Circuit No 18-3216 decided 01-28-2022.
Ratings are non-actionable opinion statements David Freydin,PC v Vitoria Chamara et al citing Syngenta Seeds Inc v. Bung North America,Inc 773 F.3d 58 (8th Cir 2014) Illinois Law on expressions of Opinion , an unexplained one star review simply could not be actionable as defamation David Freydin case citing Cf. Kimzey v. Yelp!Inc. 836 F. 3d 1263, 1269-70 (9th Cir 2016)
AEAE LEGAL ETHICS AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY EXPERTS, valuations, expert
witness testimony, trademark surveys, brief writer, Appellate Expert.
The author(s) graduated from Mayville State College with a BS Degree, North Dakota State University, MASTERS DEGREE and attended the University of Iowa a for a PHD. The Author(s) are the nation's most renowned
Legal Ethics experts and Intellectual Property Entrepreneur(s) with many years of experience in the field of brief writing, trademarks, licensing and
enforcement, expert witness testimony, trademark valuation Americans for the Enforcement of Attorney Ethics (AEAE) an attorney watch dog group since 1974. AEAE has appeared on FOX NEWS, CBS and in
numerous national news papers including the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Chicago Sun Times etc and on many radio talk shows. AEAE accepts political contributions. AEAE, P.O. Box 60645, Chicago, Illinois 60660. Email [email protected]
312-545-4554
Copyright AEAE 2017, all rights reserved. AEAE accepts no liability for incorrect or inaccurate information appearing here. The opinions expressed here are those o f AEAE Use of this site is subject to our "terms of use" which is published here. Nothing can be duplicated without written permission.
"Litigation is the Sea We swim in,
Litigation is the Air We Breathe
Litigation is War,
Welcome to the Front!"

To Prove Defamation Case?
What Do You Have To Prove? There are two things you have to prove to be true in order to win a case of defamation of character in the court of law. First of all, you have to prove without a doubt that what was said or written about you is not true. Once you have proved that the statement is, in fact, false you have to prove that the other person said the false statement with the intent of causing you some form of harm.
The Fair Reporting Privilege is a defense to any claim of Defamation

The Fair Report Privilege applies to the information contained on this web site.

“[T]he fair report privilege has two requirements: (1) the report must be of an official proceeding; and (2) the report must be complete and accurate or a fair abridgment of the official proceeding. [Citation.] *** For a publication to be considered a fair abridgment, the report must convey to readers a substantially correct account of the official proceedings. [Citation.] A reporter is not privileged to make additions of his own that would convey a defamatory impression or to indict expressly or by innuendo the veracity or integrity of any of the parties. [Citation.] Finally, it is the accuracy of the summary, not the truth or falsity of the information being summarized, that is the benchmark of the privilege. [Citation.]” (Internal quotation marks omitted.) Eubanks, 397 Ill. App. 3d at 749 (citing Solaia Technology, LLC v. Specialty Publishing Co., 221 Ill. 2d 558, 588-90 (2006)). ¶ 30
AEAE argues it reports on the law and law suits and it is the intent of AEAE to "fairly report" these official proceedings.

AEAE has the legal right to evaluate and rate attorneys, government officials, College educators, business leaders See JOHN HENRY BROWNE, et al., AVVO, INC., et al Case No. C07-0920RSL UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SEATTLE 18th day of December, 2007. A Robert S. Lasnik United States District Judge

VERITAS OMNIA VINCIT

DISCLAIMER: The AEAE does not provide legal services or legal advice. Discussions of legal principles and authority, including, but not limited to, constitutional provisions, statutes, legislative enactments, court rules, case law, and common-law doctrines are for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice.

Life at the Epicenter

3/5/2010 10:17:30 am

Hosting a Dinner Cruise on the Spirit of Chicago. Champagne and more aboard an AEAE Board of Directors meeting, Friday night. Leaving from Navy Pier 9:00PM. Amazing Chicago Sklyline views, put your Black Berries away

Face

3/5/2010 03:22:58 pm

I see you waisting your time tonight thinking you are working when you have only given every time you make to your lawyers for the last 5 years. You're going to give every time you make for the next 5 years to your lawyers.
So work hard they need the money and remember you "won" right!
By the way your attorneys are going to need another $10,000 for my latest appeal that I just filed...Tonight I just polishing my next complaint that I am going to file against you..see you in court

Last word

3/5/2010 03:29:03 pm

I told you that if you did what you did, I would sue you for the rest of my life and I am going to sue you for the rest of my life, that you can count on. When you think everything is quiet, think again because I am just drafting another complaint, motion, appeal that I will launch against you, it will "never" end, I been doing it for 42 years and I will continue as long as air in my lungs, you will be my number one target forever

3/5/2010 07:59:25 pm

Who goes on a cruise in 30 degree weather?

3/5/2010 09:33:54 pm

Are you planning on suing everyone from prison?

Stoller = Dirtbag

3/5/2010 11:30:46 pm

The posts from Stoller here are only more proof of what a low-life loser this clown is. Have fun in prison sucking cock, fuckhead.

3/6/2010 12:05:43 am

Oh Leo I was on Spirit a couple of weeks ago. We had a great time, then later on we really had a great time. Threats from you to sue me are meaningless, I figured out how to get "free" legal work. Want to guess how I do it?

FACE

3/6/2010 03:41:04 pm

I am looking forward to suing'em, your parents and any body you know. My new pleadings that I have filed will entitle me to go after your license. And if your convicted as I expect you will be, you can spend some time in the same place where I was during the last Fest. I understand that you told a lot of people where he was and you thought that was real "funny". We will see how funny you find it when you end of there. Tell you friend I will charge him with aiding and abeding a felon. It has taken me five years to dig myself out of the whole you put me in.
Within the next five years I guarrentee that you will end up in a "deeper" hole that you will have put your self into. "What comes around goes around." "Treat others as you would them treat you!"
I committed no crimes. However I got you in the commission of a class 3 felony 3-5 years and I going to press those charges against you. It's coming.
So I hope your having a "good" time so you will be able to remember it later.

Happy dreams

Anon

3/6/2010 11:23:25 pm

Stoller's use of the moniker "Face" is such a joke. The man is uglier than a donkey's rectum (and he smells worse too). Just take a look at his picture above. He looks like the slow-witted rube that he is.

Dawn

3/7/2010 08:10:42 am

I think that he is very handsome, I guess beauty is in the eye of the beholder

Stollerexposed.blog.com

3/9/2010 01:58:59 am

Just so everyone knows. Dawn is actually Leo. Yeah an AEAE cruise and you can't afford to file legal documents. Keep posting little leo cause your just digging it deeper and deeper for yourself.

Americans for the Enforcement of Attorney Ethics